Table of Contents
When it comes to choosing a fence for your home, the two most popular materials—metal and wood—each have their own advantages. Homeowners often ask:
“Are metal fences cheaper than wood?”
“Which one lasts longer?”
“What’s the best option for San Antonio weather?”
The truth is, the best fence depends on your budget, style, and long-term maintenance goals.
At Comal Fence, we’ve installed thousands of fences across San Antonio, New Braunfels, and Comal County. In this 2025 guide, we’ll help you understand the differences between metal and wood fencing, so you can make the right choice for your home.
Why Homeowners Compare Metal and Wood Fences
Wood and metal remain the top choices because they combine affordability, strength, and design flexibility. But how they perform over time can vary significantly.
| Factor | Wood Fencing | Metal Fencing |
|---|---|---|
| Upfront Cost | Lower | Higher |
| Lifespan | 15–20 yrs (cedar) | 25–50+ yrs (alum/steel/iron) |
| Maintenance | Stain/Seal regularly | Minimal (wash, spot-paint) |
| Appearance | Natural, warm, customizable | Modern, sleek, premium |
| Security | Moderate | High |
| Weather/Pest Resistance | Can warp/rot without care | Excellent with coatings |
Cost Comparison
Many homeowners assume metal fencing is more expensive—but that’s not always true when you consider longevity and maintenance.
Average Fence Costs (San Antonio 2025)
| Material | Cost per Linear Foot | Maintenance Frequency | Expected Lifespan |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pine (Wood) | $15–$25 | Every 2–3 yrs | 10–15 yrs |
| Cedar (Wood) | $25–$40 | ~Every 3 yrs | 15–20 yrs |
| Aluminum (Metal) | $30–$50 | Minimal | 25–40 yrs |
| Steel (Metal) | $35–$60 | Minimal | 30–50 yrs |
| Wrought Iron (Metal) | $40–$70+ | Minimal | 40–50 yrs |
| Notes: Ranges are planning estimates; final pricing varies by height, style, gates, terrain, and access in the San Antonio/Comal County area. | |||
Durability in San Antonio’s Climate
San Antonio’s hot summers, humidity, and storms can test any fence.
Wood fencing:
Prone to warping, rotting, and insect damage if not sealed properly.
Cedar performs better than pine due to its natural oils.
Requires regular cleaning and staining to maintain color.
Metal fencing:
Resistant to termites and weather.
Powder-coated finishes protect against rust and fading.
Ideal for high-traffic or flood-prone areas.
👉 Learn how to protect your fence after heavy rain in our recent post:
Flooded Yard? Essential Steps to Inspect and Protect Your Fence
Appearance and Design Flexibility
Wood Fencing Advantages
Natural warmth that complements traditional or ranch-style homes.
Can be painted, stained, or designed in various patterns (picket, board-on-board, horizontal).
Blends beautifully with landscaping and stone exteriors.
📌 View our Wood Fencing Services to see cedar, redwood, and pine options.
Metal Fencing Advantages
Sleek, modern appeal that matches contemporary and luxury homes.
Ideal for front yards, driveways, and gated communities.
Available in multiple styles—wrought iron, aluminum, steel panels, or chain link with privacy slats.
📌 See our Gate Installation Services for matching metal gates.
Environmental Impact
Wood
✅ Renewable resource when sourced responsibly.
❌ Shorter lifespan, requires more replacements over time.
❌ Chemical sealants can affect soil and nearby plants.
Metal
✅ Long lifespan reduces waste.
✅ Often made from recycled steel or aluminum.
✅ Fully recyclable at end of life.
If sustainability is important, metal fencing wins with its lower long-term environmental footprint.
Environmental Impact
Security is one of the biggest reasons homeowners upgrade to metal fencing.
| Feature | Wood Fence | Metal Fence |
|---|---|---|
| Strength | Moderate | Very High |
| Climb Resistance | Lower | Higher (pickets, finials) |
| Gate Automation | Available | Ideal (rigid & secure) |
| Privacy | Excellent (solid panels) | Moderate (add slats/panels) |
For homeowners prioritizing privacy, wood remains the go-to option. But if your goal is security and low maintenance, metal fences—especially wrought iron and steel—are the better investment.
Maintenance Requirements
Wood Fence Maintenance
Re-seal or stain every 2–3 years.
Inspect for rot, warping, and termites.
Power wash annually.
Metal Fence Maintenance
Clean periodically with mild soap and water.
Repaint small rust spots if they appear.
Lubricate hinges or gate mechanisms once a year.
A well-maintained metal fence can last twice as long as wood with a fraction of the effort.
Local Trends in San Antonio for 2025
Homeowners in Stone Oak, Alamo Ranch, and New Braunfels are increasingly choosing metal fences with horizontal slats for a sleek, modern appearance.
Rural properties still favor wood ranch fences for natural charm and cost savings.
Hybrid designs—metal posts with wood panels—are trending because they blend durability with aesthetics.
👉 Check out our blog: What Is a Ranch-Style Fence? for more inspiration.
Which Fence Is Right for You?
| Choose Wood If… | Choose Metal If… |
|---|---|
| You want a natural, warm look that blends with landscaping. | You prefer a modern, sleek, or luxury aesthetic. |
| You need full privacy coverage at a lower upfront cost. | You want low maintenance and a long lifespan. |
| You’re comfortable with staining/sealing every few years. | You prioritize security and compatibility with automatic gates. |
| Budget is limited and you want flexible design options. | You plan for long-term value in Texas weather. |
Conclusion
So, which is better—metal or wood fencing?
If you value privacy, tradition, and warmth, wood remains a timeless option. But if you want durability, modern appeal, and minimal upkeep, metal fencing is the clear winner for 2025.
At Comal Fence, we help homeowners across San Antonio and Comal County choose the right fencing material for their property, lifestyle, and budget.
📞 Call (210) 686-3932 or request your free quote today to compare options and get professional installation built to last.